Wiki source code of XWiki competitors
Last modified by Vincent Massol on 2022/08/22 13:25
Show last authors
author | version | line-number | content |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Discussion: [[Comparing XWiki to other solutions>>http://markmail.org/message/b52kamkbyoml55qx]] | ||
2 | |||
3 | = XWiki competitors list = | ||
4 | |||
5 | Here is the list of XWiki competitors coming from the community: | ||
6 | |||
7 | |=Name |=Editor |=Type |=Licence |=Links |=Pros and Cons against XWiki |=Kind of competition | ||
8 | |Confluence |Atlassian |Wiki | |[[Website>>http://www.atlassian.com/software/confluence/]]| |Direct | ||
9 | |Foswiki | Foswiki community|Wiki |GPL2 or later|[[Website>>http://foswiki.org/]] |very similar to XWiki: wiki+ structured data + programmable pages. Claims to have best-in-class security and WYSIWYG. |Direct | ||
10 | |TWiki | |Wiki | |[[Website>>http://twiki.org/]]| |\\ | ||
11 | |DekiWiki |Mindtouch |Wiki | |[[Website>>http://developer.mindtouch.com/Deki]] | |\\ | ||
12 | |MediaWiki | |Wiki | |[[Website>>http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/MediaWiki]] | |Direct | ||
13 | |TikiWiki | |Wiki | |[[Website>>http://info.tiki.org/Tiki+Wiki+CMS+Groupware]] | |\\ | ||
14 | |CubeTree | |Wiki | |[[Website>>https://www.cubetree.com/]] | |\\ | ||
15 | |Drupal | |CMS | |[[Website>>http://drupal.org/]] | |Medium | ||
16 | |Exo Platform |Exo |CMS | |[[Article>>http://www.slideshare.net/xwiki/wiki-vs-cms-1714023]] | |Indirect | ||
17 | |Social Text | |CMS | |[[Website>>http://www.socialtext.com/]] | |\\ | ||
18 | |Jive |Jive Software |Discussion | |[[Website>>http://www.jivesoftware.com/]] | |Complementary | ||
19 | |Google Site |Google |CMS | |[[Website>>http://sites.google.com]] | |Indirect | ||
20 | |Google Docs |Google |DMS | |[[Website>>http://docs.google.com]] | |Direct | ||
21 | |BlueKiwi | |Discussion | |[[Website>>http://www.bluekiwi-software.com/]] | |Direct | ||
22 | |Joomla | |CMS | |[[Website>>http://www.joomla.org/]] | |\\ | ||
23 | |Moodle | |Education CMS | |[[Website>>http://moodle.org/]] | |\\ | ||
24 | |Elgg | |Social Network | Open Source|[[Website>>http://elgg.org/]] | |\\ | ||
25 | |OpenCMS | |CMS | |[[Website>>http://www.opencms.org]] | |\\ | ||
26 | |Knowledge Plaza | | | |[[Website>>http://www.knowledgeplaza.net/]] | |\\ | ||
27 | |Jamespot Pro | |Social Network | |[[Website>>http://www.jamespot.pro/]] | |\\ | ||
28 | |Yoolink Pro | |Social Network | |[[Website>>http://www.yoolinkpro.com/]] | |\\ | ||
29 | |SeeMy | |Social Network | |[[Website>>http://www.seemy.eu/fr/]] | |\\ | ||
30 | |Teamshaker | |Social Network | |[[Website>>http://www.teamshaker.com/]] | |\\ | ||
31 | |Liferay | |Groupware | |[[Website>>http://www.liferay.com/]] | |\\ | ||
32 | |BlackBoard | | | |[[Website>>http://www.blackboard.com/]] | |\\ | ||
33 | |Alfresco | |CMS | |[[Website>>http://www.blackboard.com/]] | |\\ | ||
34 | |Personall | |Portal | |[[Website>>http://www.personall-software.com/J/]] | |\\ | ||
35 | |Jalios | |Social network | |[[Website>>http://www.jalios.com/]] | |\\ | ||
36 | |Silverpeas| |Portal |Open Source |[[Website>>http://www.silverpeas.com/]] | |\\ | ||
37 | |Portaneo| |Portal |Open Source |[[Website>>http://website.portaneo.com/]] | |\\ | ||
38 | |Lotus Notes|IBM |Groupware | |[[Website>>http://www.alfresco.com/]] | |Direct | ||
39 | |SharePoint|Microsoft |Groupware | |[[Website>>http://sharepoint.microsoft.com/]] |((( | ||
40 | * Pos: | ||
41 | ** Integrated as filesystem in Microsoft Office suite | ||
42 | * Cons: | ||
43 | ** More an HTTP file-system than content manager | ||
44 | )))|Direct | ||
45 | |AFFiNE|AFFiNE||Open Source|[[Website>>https://affine.pro/]]| | ||
46 | |||
47 | = Known comparison sites = | ||
48 | |||
49 | * Social Software Matrix: http://socialsoftwarematrix.org/ | ||
50 | * USEO repository: http://communaute.useo.fr/home/login?referer=%2Fhome | ||
51 | * http://www.wikimatrix.org/ | ||
52 | |||
53 | = Known used criterias to compare solutions = | ||
54 | |||
55 | |=Criteria |=Weight|= Comment | ||
56 | |Backend system requirements |critical| | ||
57 | |Extensibility |very high| The ability to add features through some sort of add ons. | ||
58 | |WYSIWYG Editor / Ease of access |very high| | ||
59 | |Usability and ergonomy |very high| | ||
60 | |MS Office Import Feature |very high| The ability to import Documents,Spreadsheets, etc directly to the wiki as a page | ||
61 | |Performance / Resources in client |high| The efficient use of web technology to keep the impact lw on the end user device. Important for the ever increasing mobile device population. Efficient use of database resources | ||
62 | |Cost |high| The cost of not only the software but also the cost of the implementation and operational costs after implementation | ||
63 | |Search |high| Ability to search not just pages, but also attachments | ||
64 | |User Management |high| Ease of setup of new users, integration to directory services, such as OpenLDAP, OpenID, Facebook, Microsoft AD | ||
65 | |Consulting / Professional support / Training |high| Availability of resources locally and via the internet for any services to support a wiki | ||
66 | |Attachments, images, etc. |high| Easy of attaching single and multiple images, and other attachments, creating galleries, adding to galleries | ||
67 | |Maintenance of the backend |high| Log Management, Database management | ||
68 | |Branding |medium| Ability to and ease of adding logo's and other artifacts such as colours to create a desired effect | ||
69 | |Categories |medium| | ||
70 | |Templates (for Site Layout) |medium| | ||
71 | |PDF Export |medium| | ||
72 | |Themes, Skins, Customizations |low| | ||
73 | |Versioning |low| | ||
74 | |Plug-Ins |low| | ||
75 | |Latex formulas |low| | ||
76 | |Comments |low| | ||
77 | |Unicode Support (e.g. for Chinese characters) |low| | ||
78 | |Localization |low| |